The Dragon Tree Blog
Welcome to the Dragon Tree Blog, your place for all things social impact communications.
By Chris Hobson, Consultant, Dragon Tree Communications, LLC
Posted on December 18, 2024
For part two of an ongoing series, we're once again looking at the numbers of U.S. children enrolled in the federal government's Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP). As I discussed in my last blog post, several U.S. states have either widened eligibility for CHIP, or are considering doing so now that the federal Covid emergency has ended.
As a recap, in the spring of 2023, a process called "Medicaid unwinding" took place where people were once again eligible to lose their Medicaid coverage based on changes in their life circumstances. To soften the blow of that unwinding, several states agreed to expand Medicaid eligibility to include more children.
Despite this, however, the unwinding has led to millions of people losing Medicaid coverage. This issue has drawn national headlines, such as this recent NBC News story that focused on large numbers of people losing their Medicaid coverage in Colorado. What the story leaves out is that Colorado has taken steps to correct this, which we'll get to in a minute.
Challenges in Colorado
According to Medicaid data, the numbers of children enrolled in Medicaid through Colorado's CHIP program have been on a steady decline ever since they hit a high of 652,517 enrollees in February of 2023. This is the month before the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 decoupled the Medicaid continuous enrollment provision from the Covid-19 public health emergency (PHE) on March 31, 2023 and resumed Medicaid disenrollments.
Currently, CHIP enrollments in Colorado are at 520,641. Here is a graph that shows the overall decline in the state up until August of 2024, the last month for which data is available:
Data courtesy of Data.Medicaid.gov
To combat these declining numbers, Colorado's Department of Health Care Policy & Financing (HCPF) recently announced that it will be extending its CHP+ coverage eligibility for children. According to the department's press release detailing the particulars of the expansion, "The policy will support continuous coverage for children from birth to age three who are eligible for Health First Colorado (Colorado’s Medicaid program) or Children’s Health Insurance program (CHP+). This expands continuous coverage for young children to 36 months, rather than the current continuous coverage of 12 months."
The change was made possible by an amendment to a Medicaid section 1115 demonstration waiver. "Through this amendment," the press release states, "HCPF expects to prevent coverage gaps for an average of 31,000 children over a 5-year demonstration period." The program goes into operation on January 1, 2026, so it will likely be a while before we see CHIP enrollment numbers start improving in the state.
National Medicaid Expansion
Colorado is one of 41 states and the District of Columbia that have expanded Medicaid. While 10 states have elected not to increase access to this safety net program, some (like Kansas) are still debating expansion. In our last blog post, we highlighted enrollment numbers in the expansion states of Maine and Arizona, a blue and swing state, respectively; for the remainder of this post, we'll zoom in on expanded enrollment in two reliably conservative states, namely North Dakota and Kansas.
Updated numbers from CMS for August 2024 CHIP enrollment were released at the end of November, so those are the numbers we'll use. As a quick reminder, there is a lag of several months in the data, so we won't be able to get up-to-the-minute numbers. That being said, let's dive in and look at the circumstances surrounding North Dakota's Medicaid expansion, how it stacks up against those of Maine and Arizona, and how the state's enrollment numbers performed through August of 2024.
CHIP Enrollment in North Dakota
As stated in our previous blog post, we chose to include North Dakota and Kansas in the mix because North Dakota is a solidly conservative state while Kansas, which is overall a conservative state, is still home to an interesting combination of conservative and liberal tendencies. Together with Maine (liberal) and Arizona (swing state), these four states constitute a spectrum of political leanings.
According to the North Dakota Health & Human Services website, "CHIP is intended to meet the needs of working families, who cannot afford health care coverage for their children, yet earn too much to qualify for Medicaid."
"To qualify," the website continues, "a family's Modified Adjusted Gross income (MAGI) must be greater than the Medicaid level, but cannot exceed 205% of the federal poverty level." This seems to be a stable benchmark that hasn't changed much in recent years.
Medicaid expansion was first enacted in North Dakota in 2014 as a result of the Affordable Care Act. While Medicaid expanded again in North Dakota as of April 1, 2024 for "individuals between 19-64 with household incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty level (FPL)," the CHIP component of the state's Medicaid program doesn't seem to have been affected.
So although North Dakota qualifies as a Medicaid expansion state, not much work seems to have been done in opening up healthcare access to more children in the state. But it's still worth asking: now that more adults are eligible for Medicaid there, might that also mean that increased awareness around enhanced Medicaid availability will prompt those adults who earn too much to qualify for Medicaid but who also still need help insuring their children to seek out insurance under the state's CHIP program?
I'm not sure how many residents fall into this category, so the premise of the question might be a long shot. But we're all about long shots here at Dragon Tree, so let's dig into the numbers and find out. First, here is a graph that looks at CHIP enrollment numbers between early 2023 and August of 2024.
Data courtesy of Data.Medicaid.gov
As you can see, CHIP enrollment is down year-over-year in the state, having declined 17.2% since the unwinding began in April of 2023. An interesting data point reported by the Kaiser Family Foundation that undercuts my premise stated above is that​, "During the unwinding of the Medicaid continuous enrollment provision, over 25 million people were disenrolled and over 56 million had their coverage renewed. Overall, 31% of people whose coverage was redetermined during the unwinding were disenrolled, but that share ranged widely across states."
Given that 45% of people were disenrolled from the state-run Medicaid program during the unwinding, that puts North Dakota in the upper fourth of states. So, although Medicaid eligibility criteria have become marginally more generous in North Dakota since the spring of 2023, not only have overall Medicaid enrollment numbers gone down, but there's also been a similar – although less drastic – downward trend of children enrolling in the CHIP program in the state.
Medicaid Expansion in Kansas
Expansion of Medicaid is still only an aspiration of some lawmakers in Kansas. Still, it's worth establishing a baseline understanding of where CHIP enrollments stand so that, in the event the state does expand Medicaid eligibility in the near future, we can track its progress more effectively.
Let's start by looking at current qualifications for CHIP enrollment in Kansas. The Division of Health Care Finance (DHCF) is responsible for purchasing health services for children through CHIP. According to the DHCF website, "Kansas provides low-cost health insurance coverage to children who are under the age of 19, do not qualify for Medicaid, have family incomes under 232% of the federal poverty level, and are not covered by private health insurance."
That means that CHIP enrollment eligibility in Kansas is more generous than in North Dakota and is on par with Arizona, where annual family income limits will soon be 225% of the federal poverty level (FPL). It isn't, however, as generous as Maine, which sets limits on household income at 300% of the FPL.
Next, let's look at CHIP enrollment numbers over the past couple of years in Kansas. Like the other states on our list, there was a drop in enrollment in March of 2023 from which the state hasn't yet bounced back:
Data courtesy of Data.Medicaid.gov
That's it for now. I'll continue watching these trends to see if the numbers turn around in 2025 and beyond. Happy Holidays, everyone!
By Chris Hobson, Consultant, Dragon Tree Communications, LLC
Posted on November 10, 2024
For the first Dragon Tree Blog post, we're looking at numbers, numbers, numbers. Here at Dragon Tree, we're interested in helping organizations help people thrive. And there's no one more in need of support these days than children.
So over a two-part blog series, we'll be diving into insurance enrollment numbers for children. The reason behind why we find this kind of exploration interesting requires a quick history lesson as to the evolution of government-sponsored health insurance over the past two years (it'll be quick, we promise!).
Setting the Stage
According to a recent report by the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, "In Q1 2024, 42.4 percent of children had public coverage and 54.2 percent had private coverage."
Also of note, between "Q2 2023 and Q1 2024…(t)he percentage of children with public coverage declined by 2.7 percentage points…"
A clarification: by "public coverage," the report is referring to government-sponsored healthcare insurance. This type of insurance takes the form of Medicare and, in the case of children and other special cases, Medicaid.
Medicaid is administered by states on behalf of a federal agency called the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, and each state has different criteria by which children qualify for it. In general, families have to earn a certain amount of income in relation to the federal poverty level to qualify.
Against this backdrop of declining public insurance coverage in the U.S., several states have begun widening eligibility criteria for government-sponsored healthcare insurance, particularly when it comes to children. During the Covid health emergency, which lasted from the early days of the pandemic until the spring of 2023, Medicaid enrollees — including children — couldn't be "dis-enrolled" from their coverage due to life events.
End of The Emergency
The federal Covid emergency lasted for about three years. When it officially ended in 2023, a process called "Medicaid unwinding" took place where people were once again eligible to lose their Medicaid coverage based on changes in their life circumstances.
To soften the blow that the unwinding occasioned, several states agreed to expand Medicaid eligibility to include more children. The process of opening up access often proves relatively long and involved given that states have to pass legislation to enact it; for this reason, only in recent months have these plans been implemented.
This brings us to the task at hand.
To help us gain insight into how expanded enrollment is going, we'll highlight enrollment numbers in four states: in blog post #1 we'll focus on Arizona and Maine, and in blog post #2, we'll hone in on North Dakota and Kansas.
We've chosen these states because they represent the entire political spectrum: one of these states is reliably liberal (Maine), one is a swing state (Arizona), and two are reliably conservative states (North Dakota and Kansas). This should give us a good sense of the varieties of expansion on offer as they relate to children, and to what degree they're proving successful.
The Children's Health Insurance Program
In this post, we'll confine our inquiries to enrollment in the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP). CHIP is an adjunct to Medicaid that provides "low-cost health coverage to children in families that earn too much money to qualify for Medicaid." Several states focused on expanding access to this program as the continuous enrollment condition authorized by the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) came to a close in the spring of 2023.
In all of these states (with the exception of Kansas), the expansions have only recently taken effect. Kansas is a special case, since expanding CHIP eligibility to cover more children has been the subject of debate there for some time now, but hasn't yet passed. Because of this, I thought it would be interesting to compare Kansas' current Medicaid child enrollment numbers to those of states where CHIP expansion has taken place.
We'll take a look at numbers available at data.medicaid.gov to review the first few months of data rolling in. This data set collected by Medicaid is lagging by about four months, so the latest update on October 31st only measures enrollee numbers through July of 2024.
While this is a very small window of time that will yield little in the way of patterns from which we can draw any sort of conclusions, it will at least give us an idea of preliminary numbers. We plan to continue watching how these numbers move over time.
CHIP Enrollment in Arizona
Let's start with Arizona.
As part of the state budget approval process in 2023, Governor Katie Hobbs and the state legislature agreed on an expansion of KidsCare, which is the name of Arizona's CHIP program. The decision, which enjoyed bipartisan support, allowed KidsCare to expand eligibility to cover more children by increasing family income limits.
According to the KidsCare website, "To qualify for KidsCare, annual family income limits are rising to 225% of the federal poverty level, or an annual household income of up to $70,200 for a family of four."
Since the expansion took effect on March 1, 2024, we thought it would be interesting to look at the first few months of data.
Up first is a graph tracking enrollment rates between May and July of 2024.
Data courtesy of data.medicaid.gov
Curiously, unlike other states on the list, there isn't much data for CHIP enrollment numbers in Arizona prior to May of 2024. As stated above, since access expansion only began in March of this year in Arizona, there isn't much data available. As a consequence, this graph can't tell us much of anything aside from the fact that CHIP enrollment numbers have fallen slightly since families started enrolling their children under the expansion. Again, we'll keep an eye on these numbers to see what happens over time.
CHIP Enrollment in Maine
Now on to Maine. It's important to note that while the CHIP expansion has already been approved, it didn't take effect until August of 2024; consequently, since our data source only has updated numbers through July of 2024, we won't see the expansion reflected in the figures just yet.
But that's OK! We can at least visualize the starting point, and then see if it moves over time.
For now, let's familiarize ourselves with the particulars of Maine's expansion. According to the State of Maine Health and Human Services website, the following is true relative to the eligibility standards for children under the age of 21 in Maine's CHIP program:
"Part 5, Section 6, Income Standard increases the household income for all children from 208% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) to 300% of the FPL effective retroactive to October 1, 2023."
So a few things are going on here that are different from Arizona, namely that household income requirements are a bit more generous (300% of the Federal Poverty Level in Maine, compared to 225% in Arizona), and enrollment is retroactive to an earlier date than Arizona's eligibility date.
That being the case, here is a chart looking at CHIP enrollment rates going back a bit further in time, to January of 2023:
Data courtesy of data.medicaid.gov
We expanded our time frame here because we think it's important to show that CHIP enrollment has been relatively consistent in Maine over the past couple of years, with the exception of a dip in the summer and fall of 2023. This will provide important context as we watch these rates over time.
That's it for now! In our next blog post, we'll examine CHIP expansion in the more conservative states on our list, North Dakota and Kansas.